Gem of the Week: Porn Exchange

As a publicity stunt, it seems a cabal of Godless young enterprisers at the University of Texas at San Antonio are offering their fellow students porn in exchange for their bibles.  According to the student atheist group, pornography is no worse than the text of the Bible, so why not do a fair exchange?  Well, not to get too technical, but the standard dictionary definition of pornography is: “films, magazines, writings, photographs, or other materials that are sexually explicit and intended to cause sexual arousal.” (Emphasis added.)  While there appear to be arguments out there (way out there) that the Bible contains some passages that could be interpreted as slightly suggestive (eg., The Old Testament’s Song of Solomon), one can hardly seriously argue that these rise to the level of sexual explicitness intending to cause arousal.  Or to put it another way, if you’re reaching for the Bible to get your jollies, you’re pretty pathetic.

At any rate, there is nothing novel about yet another group of self-important college students employing sophomoric shock tactics to seek attention.  However, what is news is the school’s reaction to the event.  When asked for comment, school officials mildly replied that the atheist group is perfectly within its legal rights to conduct the swap.  According to University Spokesman David Gabler: “As long as students are not violating laws or violating the Constitution, they have the freedom of speech and assembly.”  He elaborated, “We are a marketplace of free ideas here at UTSA, and our students have all constitutional rights afforded to all individuals in the United States.”

Well isn’t that nice.  Apparently, the school is not the least bit scandalized by any of this.    At a time when colleges seem to think of every reason under the sun why a conservative group cannot have this or that speaker appear on campus, how refreshing it is to see the open-minded University of Texas officials suddenly standing up for free speech and assembly in the marketplace of ideas.  Given this new laissez-faire approach, one wonders if they would be quite so accommodating of other groups employing similarly obscene tactics.  Suppose a Christian student group decided to do a Bible for Quran exchange?  What if a white supremacist student group offered an exchange of Hitler’s Mein Kampf for copies of the Torah?  Or an even greater sacrilege: an exchange of Mein Kampf for Barrack Obama’s The Audacity of Hope.  Would the liberal thinking administrators of the University of Texas still be so tepidly neutral?

Our rights are guaranteed under the Constitution and are there for our protection, not for our abuse.  On the spectrum of bad examples the school could set for its students, the only thing worse than condoning the abuse of a right (in this case free speech), is the picking and choosing of when and for whom a right applies, and when and for whom it does not.  And that is nothing short of obscene.

For a related post, link to:

https://culturecrusader.wordpress.com/2010/03/23/gem-of-the-week-oh-canada-what-a-houles-you-are/

Advertisements

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

7 Responses to “Gem of the Week: Porn Exchange”

  1. goldnsilver Says:

    Though I agree with you that this sounds like a bunch of crass dickheads who are attention seeking I would like to bring your attention to some points.

    I’m Australian, yet I read a lot of blogs on the internet. One thing I have noticed is that the Christians and the Atheists in America seem to both attack and defend when it comes to the freedom of speech issue. Both sides feel that they are censored and that the other is inappropriate.

    Have a look at this blog:

    http://www.blaghag.com/

    It’s about an atheist university student. She has often attended campus run Christian events where they have openly called Atheists every name under the sun.

    All I’m saying is that it happens to both sides.

  2. urbisaereperennius Says:

    Are you against laissez-faire policies in economics as well? Some puerile publicity stunt done in colleges isn’t deeply threatening to Western civilization is it? I would hope not; I figured it was made of sterner stuff than that.

  3. culturecrusader Says:

    Urb,
    No. And I’m not against, per se, laissez-faire being applied on the college campus either. What I am against is the hypocrisy of applying it in a biased way (i.e., being hands off so long as the speech in question furthers a counter-culture agenda, yet meddling when it has to deal with right-wing or traditional issues.)

    • goldnsilver Says:

      Did you read my comment or click on the link? The point I was making is that ‘meddling’ also happens with so called ‘counter-culture’, just as it does with ‘traditional values’. It cuts both ways.

      If both sides weren’t always trying to shut the other side up, things might improve.

      Until you recognise this, you’re just repeating what you want to hear.

  4. Gem of the Week: Oh Canada, What A-Houles You Are! « Culture Crusader Says:

    […] https://culturecrusader.wordpress.com/2010/03/06/gem-of-the-week-2/ […]

  5. Example of an Ignorant Conservative « fandecande Says:

    […] https://culturecrusader.wordpress.com/2010/03/06/gem-of-the-week-2/ 8 Votes […]

  6. Gem of the Week: Wear the American Flag to School and Get Sent Home « Culture Crusader Says:

    […] https://culturecrusader.wordpress.com/2010/03/06/gem-of-the-week-2/ […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: